How Social Media Can Ruin Your Car Accident Case

Sharing life updates, photos, and thoughts online has become second nature for many people. But if you’ve recently been hurt in a car accident, that innocent Instagram post or casual Facebook comment could come back to haunt you—especially if you’re seeking injury compensation.

Here’s how social media affects personal injury cases and what you can do to protect your claim.

How Insurance Companies Use Social Media

Insurance adjusters and opposing attorneys are looking for evidence to challenge your credibility, your version of events, or the seriousness of your injuries. Part of this investigation includes your Facebook, Instagram, Reddit, X, and any other public social media platforms. Social media gives them a goldmine of information, often without a subpoena.

Can Facebook Ruin My Car Accident Case?

What you post—or what others post about you—can and will be used against you if it helps insurers reduce or deny your compensation.

A photo, status update, or tagged post contradicting your injury claim can severely damage your case. Pictures of yourself on a weekend trip—even if you’re still in pain—may be used as “evidence.” Even a simple status update like “Feeling better today” can be taken out of context.

Social Media Mistakes in Injury Cases

Anything you post online that gives the appearance of physical activity, emotional well-being, or inconsistent behavior can be used to argue that you’re not as injured as you say you are.

Common online activities that can cause problems with injury cases include:

1. Posting Photos or Videos of Yourself Being Active

Suppose you suffered a back injury in a crash. A week later, a friend posts a group photo from a birthday dinner showing you standing and smiling. Even if you were in pain the entire time and just posed for a few minutes, an adjuster might use that image to argue your injuries aren’t serious.

2. Talking About the Accident

You may feel compelled to share your story, especially if it was traumatic. But even well-meaning posts like “Feeling sore but lucky to be alive after the wreck yesterday” can backfire. Any statements you make about how the crash happened or how you’re feeling can be twisted out of context.

3. Checking in or Sharing Locations

If you check in at the gym, a restaurant, or on a hike—even if you’re just there for a short time—it could be used to dispute your physical limitations. Don’t tag yourself at events, outings, or locations. It’s easy for the other side to argue that your presence in certain places contradicts your injury testimony.

4. Engaging in Comments or Arguments

Posting angry responses about the other driver or venting about the claim process can damage your case. These posts may be portrayed as emotionally unstable or uncooperative behavior.

5. Not Adjusting Your Privacy Settings

Even if your profile is private, that doesn’t guarantee safety. Insurance companies can still access information through mutual friends, tagged posts, or by requesting discovery in a legal case.

6. Deleting Posts You Think Are Incriminating

If you’ve posted something questionable before realizing the risks, don’t panic—and don’t delete it without speaking to your lawyer. Deleting posts could be seen as tampering with evidence, especially if your claim ends up in court. Instead, screenshot the post and bring it to your lawyer’s attention; we will help you control the narrative.

Posting After a Car Accident

You don’t have to disappear from the internet completely during recovery, but you do need to take precautions. Here’s how to reduce the risk of social media damaging your car accident case:

Set Account Restrictions

Set your profile to “private.” Go through your contact list and remove or block anyone you don’t know personally. Disable post tagging and timeline review features. Avoid accepting new friend requests during your case, especially from strangers.

Limit Social Media Use

The safest approach is to stop posting until your claim is resolved. If you must stay online, avoid discussing the accident, your injuries, your recovery, or any legal proceedings.

Ask Friends and Family Not to Post About You

Even if you stay off social media, someone else’s post that includes your name, tag, or image can create problems. Politely ask those close to you to respect your privacy and avoid sharing anything about your activities, especially if you appear in photos or videos.

Never Discuss Your Case Publicly

Don’t talk about legal strategies, insurance companies, settlement offers, or your lawyer. This type of content can violate confidentiality and be used against you during negotiations or at trial.

Ask Our Indiana Car Accident Attorneys How to Handle Online Accounts

After a car accident, seeking support and connection online is natural. But what you post during this time can tip the scales from a fair injury settlement to a denied claim. Protect yourself by getting experienced legal help.

At Wilson Kehoe Winingham, we can fight improper discovery requests, prepare the right strategy, and give you the guidance you need to win your case. Call us at (317) 920-6400 or contact us for a free, no-obligation case evaluation.

Share This Article