Call or Text Us For A Free Case Evaluation: 317.920.6400 | 800.525.8028 Search Site

Florida Decision Puts Cruise Ships in Liability Spotlight

January 30, 2015 Medical Malpractice, Personal Injury, Wrongful Death

Florida Decision Puts Cruise Ships in Liability SpotlightWhen negligence occurs at a hospital, patients or their families may be entitled to compensation for things like medical expenses and pain and suffering. While this applies in many medical settings, some might be surprised to learn that cruise ship companies were exempt from medical malpractice suits for more than a century. However, the AP reports that a recent decision in Florida’s 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals may change the way cases involving cruise ships are handled.

Injured During A Cruise

After an 82-year-old man from New York City fell and hit his head in Bermuda in 2011, a nurse on a Royal Caribbean ship told him to rest. The man’s family filed a suit because they allege that the nurse did not suggest a diagnostic scan and that it took hours for the man to be examined by a doctor when his condition worsened. By the time a doctor saw the man, he had internal bleeding in his skull and could not be saved.

The Defense

Over a century of court decisions have protected cruise ships when suits like this one occurred, because courts ruled that the medical care provided on a ship differs from what is available on land. This means that passengers should not expect the same standard of care while on a ship. Additionally, the medical staff on many ships were not cruise line employees but private contractors.

A representative of Royal Caribbean said the previous rules for cruise ships should be upheld, and noted that the cruise line primarily offers vacations, not health care.

New Court Ruling

The court in Florida ruled that the exemption for cruise ships was outdated. In Royal Caribbean’s case, the medical staff wore the same uniforms as the other employees and were advertised as ship employees. The ship’s medical center was also praised when described in promotional material. If this decision is upheld, those alleging medical malpractice aboard cruise ships could have their cases heard by Florida courts.

Little Data

There is scant data on cruise ship incidents like this one, because these ships operate as overseas entities. One enterprising individual started CruiseJunkie.com to keep the public informed, and one chart in particular shows that 244 passengers and crew have fallen overboard since 2000. Among those, an average of 20 passengers a year have gone missing.

Despite their location, doctors and nurses are trusted to offer patients the best care possible. If you or a loved one received substandard care, a medical malpractice lawyer could provide assistance when seeking the compensation you deserve. Contact us when interested about your options.

Request A Free Case Evaluation

Fill out the form below to receive a free and confidential initial consultation.

Submitting your information does not automatically create an attorney-client relationship. I agree