Contact WKW
Our Address
2859 N. Meridian St.
Indianapolis, IN 46208
Office
317.920.6400
Free Case Evaluation
317.920.6400
Medical Malpractice Lawyers Medical Malpractice Lawyer Blog Missouri Supreme Court Strikes Down Medical Malpractice Damages Cap
Request a Free ConsultationUpdated June 19, 2025 | By Wilson Kehoe Winingham staff
Last week, the Supreme Court of Missouri struck down a 2005 state law that limited the amount of non-economic damages a jury may award in medical malpractice cases. The ruling has sparked new conversations about medical malpractice caps and how they affect a patient’s access to fair compensation. In a 4-3 decision, the Court stated the $350,000 limit imposed on damages for pain and suffering violated a patient’s right to a jury trial.
In Watts v. Cox Medical Centers, et al., a Springfield, Missouri mother filed a lawsuit after her son sustained catastrophic brain damage during his birth. A jury determined the hospital’s delay in providing Deborah Watts with an emergency Cesarean section caused her son’s brain injury and awarded the new mother almost $5 million as a result.
The jury’s $1.45 million non-economic damages award was reduced, however, pursuant to the 2005 law. Watts subsequently appealed her son’s case to the Missouri Supreme Court. Chief Justice Richard B. Teitelman said the Court’s decision to strike down the so-called tort reform law will ensure that Watts’s son will receive the benefit of the jury’s decision to provide compensation for his future medical expenses and care.
The Missouri Chamber of Commerce and Industry expressed disappointment with the Court’s decision. Missouri House Judiciary Committee Chairman Stanley Cox said the holding was a reversal of an earlier decision that held a damages cap does not violate an individual’s right to a jury trial. In response to the decision, some Missouri legislators stated they would consider asking voters to reinstate the medical malpractice caps through a constitutional amendment. Senator Rob Schaaf said a constitutional amendment would also prevent the possibility of a veto by the current Governor.
In contrast, Tim Dollar, President of the Missouri Association of Trial Attorneys, applauded the high court’s decision. Both patient advocates and plaintiff’s attorneys believe the non-economic damages cap unfairly targets children and the elderly, who do not normally receive an award for lost wages following a catastrophic injury.
Although the average number of medical malpractice lawsuits filed since the 2005 law was passed has decreased from 847 per year to 643, the number of jury verdicts in favor of Missouri plaintiffs remained steady at one percent. Additionally, the Missouri Foundation for Health reported the damages cap failed to reduce healthcare costs in the state. Attorney Jeffrey Herman believes fewer medical mistakes may result from a lack of a damages cap, as physicians and other healthcare providers will have an increased incentive to be cautious when providing patient care.
Randy Erickson2024-08-16 Our Father died from a fall due to negligence at the facility he was at for rehab. Our family is grateful for Kent Winingham and Maria Dicken for their support and dedication to our case. Kent has a thorough knowledge of Indiana laws and prepared a successful case. They answered all of our questions and kept us informed during the entire process. Our family would highly recommend WKW. Rachael Stone2024-07-16 Kent and Maria were absolutely amazing to work with!!! You can tell that they genuinely care about you and your family and the case. They take time to explain everything to you in words that you will understand. And they did AMAZING with our case and fought hard for our family and won. Thank you so much for all you guys did for our family, especially in a time of sadness!!! I highly recommend Wilson Kehoe Winingham you definitely will not be disappointed at all! DAVID RUSSELL2024-07-12 “ Kent Winingham and his Paralegal Angie were there to assist my Son and I throughout the entire process from start to finish in two different cases. Kent and his staff helped us navigate the unique challenges that presented themselves in these particular cases. Kent and his staff was thorough, diligent, and professional, handling our cases in a timely manner. Kent and his staff were patient with us and communicative at all times, involving us in every step. I highly recommend Atty. Kent Winningham and his staff at Wilson Kehoe Winingham. Ron Bryan Sr2024-06-04 Nice people to talk to and work with. Would recommend to anyone needing a good law firm. Michael Lennartz2024-06-03 The whole team at WKW worked tirelessly to help us receive compensation after an auto accident. Bill Winingham personally visited us in Lafayette to talk about the case and contacted us after hours several times to discuss issues. Our paralegal, Cynthia, was wonderful as she helped us gather all the information needed to provide evidence in our case. Additionally, as the case unexpectedly dragged on, everyone at WKW continued to be patient and optimistic as we finally worked towards a successful outcome in our case. Jennifer Peterson2024-03-26 After suffering a life changing work related injury, I was left with no other choice than to reach out to an attorney to assist me with getting financial assistance for my past and future medical bills. The first attorney I worked with in Massachusetts stated they would be able to assist me with my case but ultimately stated it was in my best interest to reach out to a law firm in the state where the accident took place. So I had to start researching the Indianapolis area and spoke to a few attorneys who stated that they didn't feel I had a good case and therefore couldn't assist me. Finally after almost giving up hope, I was referred to Wilson Kehoe Winingham. I called and spoke with Bill Winingham and Jon Noyes who were expecting my call. They both listened to my story and immediately stated I did have a case and they would be happy to help. The process was long and I had to make a few trips to Indianapolis to meet with them and the judge but in the end they helped me. I always felt like they had my best interest at heart and gave me honest feedback at all times. I would highly recommend them and the firm if you ever find yourself in need a assistance. I can't say enough about them. Chelsea Moore2024-03-07 I was referred to use Kent Winingham for an injury I had suffered in an auto accident. I was nothing but pleased! Kent and his team went above and beyond to make sure that I got every penny I deserved! He was a great listener, great negotiator, and EXTREMELY prepared! If you find yourself needing legal help due to injury look no further than Kent Winingham! Thanks again Kent!
Many states have passed a variety of so-called tort reform laws that include an arbitrary cap for non-economic damages. Non-economic damages normally include pain and suffering, grief, loss of companionship, and other injuries that are not easily calculable.
In 1975, the State of Indiana placed a cap on all damages caused by medical malpractice. Despite the cap, the cost of healthcare in the state has continued to increase at an alarming rate.
If you or a loved one have been injured as a result of medical negligence, you are urged to contact the attorneys of Wilson Kehoe Winingham. An experienced Indianapolis medical malpractice lawyer at WKW can help you get the compensation you deserve. Call 317.920.6400 or fill out an online contact form for a free, no-obligation case evaluation.
Transcript Right now with Indiana medical malpractice law, we have a statutory cap on damages set at $1,250,000.00. It has changed over the year, but…
Medical malpractice and medical negligence are different but very much related in that medical malpractice is a kind of negligence. The distinction between the two…
Transcript Malpractice is another name for negligence, and negligence means the failure to exercise reasonable care. When we look at a doctor or a nurse,…
Let WKW put our experience to work for you. Contact us for your free case evaluation.
Or, call us today at (317) 920-6400