Who Should You Call First After a Car Accident in Indianapolis: Police, Insurance, or a Lawyer?

After a car accident in Indianapolis, call 911 first if anyone is injured or emergency assistance is needed. Next, promptly notify your own insurance company, as your policy requires. If the other driver’s insurance company requests a recorded statement, consider speaking with an Indianapolis car accident lawyer before agreeing.

The order matters. Indiana law sets certain reporting duties, while your insurance policy creates separate notice requirements. Knowing the difference can help you avoid mistakes that affect your coverage or injury claim.

Do You Have to Call the Police in Indiana?

Indiana law requires drivers to notify law enforcement immediately when a crash causes injury or death to another person. Under Indiana Code § 9-26-1-1.1, drivers must also provide reasonable assistance to injured or trapped people.

If a crash damages an unattended vehicle or other property, drivers must make reasonable efforts to locate its owner. If the owner cannot be found, they must contact law enforcement.

Indiana Code § 9-26-2-1 also requires a police investigation when a crash causes injury, death, or property damage that meets the statutory threshold. These rules apply to crashes on Indianapolis roads, including I-465, I-65, and city streets.

If officers do not respond, ask the appropriate police agency how to document the collision. Do not assume the absence of an officer eliminates your reporting responsibilities.

When Should You Call Your Own Insurance Company?

Notify your own car insurance company promptly after an Indianapolis accident, regardless of who caused it. Most auto insurance policies contain notice and cooperation provisions that require policyholders to report crashes within a reasonable time.

When contacting your insurer, provide accurate basic information, including the date, location, drivers involved, and known damage or injuries.

You should also:

  • Ask about applicable reporting deadlines.
  • Obtain your claim number.
  • Confirm what information your policy requires.

If you do not yet know the extent of your injuries, say so rather than guessing.

Reporting a crash to your own insurer is different from providing a recorded statement to the other driver’s insurance company. Delaying required notice to your insurer can create separate coverage issues.

Should You Talk to the Other Driver’s Insurance Company Before Calling a Lawyer?

You generally do not have to give the other driver’s insurance company a recorded statement before speaking with an attorney. Indiana follows a fault-based insurance system, meaning the responsible driver’s liability coverage generally pays covered losses.

The other driver’s insurance adjuster investigates the claim for that insurer, not for you.

A recorded statement can create problems when:

  • You describe injuries before symptoms fully develop.
  • You speculate about who caused the crash.
  • Your early statements differ from later medical findings.

You can provide basic information without agreeing to a recorded interview immediately. Consider consulting an attorney before discussing fault, injuries, or settlement with the opposing insurer.

Does Calling a Lawyer First Change Anything with the Police or Your Insurer?

Calling a lawyer does not eliminate your duty to report an accident to police or notify your own insurance company. It primarily changes how you handle communications with the other driver’s insurer.

At Wilson Kehoe Winingham Injury Lawyers, our attorneys have 124 years of combined experience handling injury matters. Attorney W. Kent Winingham received the Indiana Trial Lawyers Association’s Young Lawyer of the Year award, while attorney Jon Noyes earned its Trial Lawyer of the Year honor.

Their experience with Indiana injury claims can help accident victims evaluate requests for statements, preserve evidence, and understand the insurance claims process.

What Should You Do if You’ve Already Given a Statement to the Other Driver’s Insurer?

If you already gave a recorded statement, you can still consult an Indianapolis car accident attorney. An early statement does not automatically prevent you from pursuing an injury claim.

Request a copy of the statement, keep your correspondence, and document any symptoms or medical findings that developed afterward.

An attorney can review what you said and assess whether the statement affects your claim. Avoid changing your account without explaining why additional information is necessary. 

Contact Wilson Kehoe Winingham Injury Lawyers today for a free consultation with an Indianapolis car accident lawyer.

If you’ve been injured or are facing a complex legal matter, reach out to Wilson Kehoe Winingham Injury Lawyers to schedule a consultation. Our team serves clients across Indianapolis and throughout Indiana, and we’re ready to pursue the justice and full compensation you deserve.

2859 N Meridian St
Indianapolis, IN 46208

(317) 920-6400